News

Most thyroid nodules have favorable prognosis

View on the News

More efficient, cost-effective follow-up needed

Thyroid nodules are pervasive, whereas thyroid cancer is not. The findings from Durante et al represent an important step in improving the efficiency and mitigating the expense of follow-up for the vast majority of thyroid nodules that are either cytologically or sonographically benign.

These prospective data provide reassurance about the validity of a benign cytology result obtained by ultrasound-guided fine-needle aspiration and confirm a very low false-negative rate, at 1.1%. The practice of routine sonographic surveillance with repeat fine-needle aspiration for growth, as recommended by published guidelines, is not the most efficient strategy to detect the very small number of missed cancers among previously sampled cytologically benign nodules. The one-size-fits-all approach simply does not work. Instead, surveillance strategies should be individualized based on a nodule’s sonographic appearance.

Many nodules detected on ultrasound are small (less than 1 cm) and not sonographically suspicious. In the study by Durante et al, only one cancer was diagnosed during follow-up among the 852 sonographically benign nodules that were smaller than 1 cm. Of note, the trigger for fine-needle aspiration for this nodule was development of hypoechogenicity and irregular margins, not growth.

Although 69% of nodules [in the study] remained stable in size, size increase was not a harbinger of malignancy, especially if the nodule had no sonographically suspicious features.

Anne R. Cappola, M.D., Sc.M., and Susan J. Mandel, M.D., M.P.H., are with the University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia. Dr. Cappola is also an associate editor of JAMA. These comments are based on their accompanying editorial (JAMA 2015 March 3 [doi:10.1001/jama.2015.0836]).


 

FROM JAMA

References

During 5 years of follow-up, cancer arose in only 0.3% of thyroid nodules that were cytologically and sonographically benign at baseline, according to a large prospective study published online March 3 in JAMA.

Furthermore, only two of the five nodules that became cancerous had grown beforehand, reported Dr. Cosimo Durante of the Sapienza University of Rome and his associates. “These data suggest that the American Thyroid Association’s recommendation for indication for repeat cytology should be revised. Clinical and sonographic findings should probably play larger roles in the decision-making process,” the researchers said (JAMA 2015;313:926-35).

©Sebastian Kaulitzki/Fotolia.com

Advances in diagnostic imaging have increased the detection of thyroid nodules, the great majority of which are found to be benign. For such nodules, the ATA recommends repeating thyroid ultrasonography at 6-18 months and then every 3-5 years thereafter, as long as nodules do not significantly grow (defined as at least a 20% increase in two nodule diameters, with a minimum increase of at least 2 mm [Thyroid 2009;19:1167-214]). But little is known about rate, extent, or predictors of nodule growth, the researchers noted. Therefore, they performed annual thyroid ultrasound examinations on 992 patients who had one to four asymptomatic subcentimeter thyroid modules that were cytologically or sonographically benign at baseline.

After 5 years of follow-up, just 15.4% of patients had experienced significant nodule growth according to the ATA definition, the researchers reported. Average growth was 4.9 mm, and 9.3% of patients developed new nodules, of which one was found to be cancerous. Growth was least likely when a patient’s largest nodule measured 7.5 mm or less and was significantly more likely when patients had multiple nodules instead of one; had baseline nodule volume greater than 0.2 mL; were up to 45 years old, compared with at least 60 years of age; and were male, the investigators said.

Among older patients, having a body mass index of 28.6 kg/m2 more than doubled the odds of nodule growth, in keeping with recent reports linking obesity and insulin resistance with nodular thyroid disease, they added.

The findings suggest that repeat thyroid ultrasonography could be safely extended to 12 months for initial follow-up and to every 5 years thereafter for most patients, as long as nodule size remained stable, Dr. Durante and his associates said. “This approach should be suitable for about 85% of patients, whose risk of disease progression is low. Closer surveillance may be appropriate for nodules occurring in younger patients or older overweight individuals with multiple nodules, large nodules (greater than 7.5 mm), or both,” they added.

The Umberto Di Mario Foundation, Banca d’Italia, and the Italian Thyroid Cancer Observatory Foundation funded the study. The authors reported having no conflicts of interest.

Recommended Reading

No survival benefit of RAI seen in early-stage thyroid cancer
MDedge Hematology and Oncology
Moderate THST linked to improved survival in thyroid cancer
MDedge Hematology and Oncology
Enhanced thyroid cancer guidelines expected in 2015
MDedge Hematology and Oncology
Total thyroidectomy more likely with younger thyroid cancer patients
MDedge Hematology and Oncology
Radioactive iodine may boost survival in papillary thyroid cancer
MDedge Hematology and Oncology
High failure rate seen with limited parathyroidectomy in patients with MEN-1
MDedge Hematology and Oncology
Regional lymph node mets not a risk factor for death in adrenocortical carcinoma
MDedge Hematology and Oncology
Ultrasound bests elastography for specificity of thyroid cancer diagnosis
MDedge Hematology and Oncology
Study aims to determine prognostic factors for subset of thyroid cancer patients
MDedge Hematology and Oncology
Lenvima gets the FDA’s nod for differentiated thyroid cancer
MDedge Hematology and Oncology